|
ESL Forum:
Techniques and methods
in Language Teaching
Games, activities
and teaching ideas
Grammar and
Linguistics
Teaching material
Concerning
worksheets
Concerning
powerpoints
Concerning online
exercises
Make suggestions,
report errors
Ask for help
Message board
|
ESL forum >
Grammar and Linguistics > active or passive?
active or passive?
|
|
goodnesses
|
Hi , memthefirst
Yes both "structures" are correct and used very often.
However, the second one "X have/has/had Sth done" or "X have/has/had Sb do Sth" (=X assigned Sb to do the job for him) is to be used more carefully because it can lead to some strange meaning.
How could it be some one can ask some one else to break his/her leg?
|
8 Dec 2008
|
|
|
goodnesses
|
Just some more details/
From: Cambridge English Grammar in Use
UNIT 45. Have something done
A. Study this example situation:
The roof of Jill�s house was damaged in a storm, so she arranged for somebody to repair it. Yesterday a
workman came and did the job.
Jill had the roof repaired yesterday.
This means: Jill arranged for somebody else to repair the roof. She didn�t repair it herself.
We use have something done to say that we arrange for somebody else to do something for us.
Compare:
* Jill repaired the roof. (= she repaired it herself)
* Jill had the roof repaired. (= she arranged for somebody else to repair it)
Study these sentences:
* Did Ann make the dress herself or did she have it made?
* �Are you going to repair the car yourself?� �No, I�m going to have it repaired.�
Be careful with word order. The past participle (repaired/cut etc.) is after the object (the roof your hair etc.):
have + object + past participle
Jill had the roof repaired yesterday.
Where did you have your hair cut?
Your hair looks nice. Have you had it cut?
Julia has just had central heating installed in her house.
We are having the house painted at the moment.
How often do you have your car serviced?
I think you should have that coat cleaned soon.
I don�t like having my photograph taken.
B. You can also say �get something done� instead of �have something done� (mainly in informal spoken
English):
* When are you going to get the roof repaired? (= have the roof repaired)
* I think you should get your hair cut.
C. Sometimes have something done has a different meaning. For example:
* Jill and Eric had all their money stolen while they were on holiday.
Of course this does not mean that they arranged for somebody to steal their money. �They had all their
money stolen� means only: �All their money was stolen from them.�
With this meaning, we use have something done to say that something happens to somebody or their
belongings. Usually what happens is not nice:
* George had his nose broken in a fight.
* Have you ever had your passport stolen?
|
10 Dec 2008
|
|
< Previous
1
2
|
