|   
			ESL Forum: 
			
			
			
			Techniques and methods 
			in Language Teaching 
			
			Games, activities 
			and teaching ideas 
			
			Grammar and 
			Linguistics 
			
			
			Teaching material 
			
			
			Concerning 
			worksheets 
			
			
			Concerning 
			powerpoints 
			
			
			Concerning online 
			exercises 
			
			
			Make suggestions, 
			report errors 
			
			
			Ask for help 
			
			
			
			Message board 
			  
			
			
			
			
			 | 
 		
		
		ESL forum >
		
		
		Grammar and Linguistics > past continuous in reported speech     
			
		 past continuous in reported speech 
		
			| 
				
					| 
					
					
 
 cristinasuma
 
   | 
						
							| past continuous in reported speech 
 |  
							| I have a question regarding Reported Speech. When the reporting verb is in the past, I know that some verb tenses can change or not. If the verb is in the past progressive some grammars say you must change it into the past perfect progressive while some grammars say it is not necessary to change it.   My example is:                 "One week ago I was lying on the beach", Christine said   Options:             Christine said one week before she had been lying on the beach              Christine said one week before she was lying on the beach   Can you tell me if the second option is correct? If so, is there any case when the change to past perfect progressive is advisable or compulsory?   Many thanks |  30 May 2012      
					
					 |  |  
			| 
 
					
					
					
				 
 |  
			|  |  
			| 
				
					| 
					
					
 
 cristinasuma
 
   | 
						
							| Hi "ascincoquinas",  It is clearer now.                                         Thanks a lot |  30 May 2012     
					
                     |  |  
	
	   |