|   
			ESL Forum: 
			
			
			
			Techniques and methods 
			in Language Teaching 
			
			Games, activities 
			and teaching ideas 
			
			Grammar and 
			Linguistics 
			
			
			Teaching material 
			
			
			Concerning 
			worksheets 
			
			
			Concerning 
			powerpoints 
			
			
			Concerning online 
			exercises 
			
			
			Make suggestions, 
			report errors 
			
			
			Ask for help 
			
			
			
			Message board 
			  
			
			
			
			
			 | 
 		
		
		ESL forum >
		
		
		Grammar and Linguistics > Grammar Question     
			
		 Grammar Question 
		
			| 
				
					| 
					
					
 
 Jennings Teacher
 
   | 
						
							| Grammar Question 
 |  
							| Why is "as they have" wrong in the following sentence? 
 
 "Well, real escapologists have less excitement than they are depicted as they have."  
 
 I know it �s wrong and should be "as having" instead of "as they have" but I have no idea why it is wrong or how to explain it. Can anyone help me?   |  1 Jul 2012      
					
					 |  |  
			| 
 
					
					
					
				 
 |  
			| 
				
					| 
					
					
 
 Apodo
 
   | 
						
							| It is the way we use depicted.We say: 
They (Escapologists) are depicted as having a lot of excitement.  
 Australians are usually depicted as being sun-tanned and sports-loving, but of course many of us aren �t.   We don�t say: 
They are depicted as they have a lot of excitement.         
 
   
 |  2 Jul 2012     
					
                     |  |  
	
	   |