ESL Forum:
Techniques and methods
in Language Teaching
Games, activities
and teaching ideas
Grammar and
Linguistics
Teaching material
Concerning
worksheets
Concerning
powerpoints
Concerning online
exercises
Make suggestions,
report errors
Ask for help
Message board
|
ESL forum >
Ask for help > Sī OR SīS??
Sī OR SīS??

kiaras
|
Sī OR SīS??
|
DEAR FRIENDS: I NEED YOUR HELP! CAN YOU PLEASE TELL ME WHAT THE RULES ARE FOR THE Sī WHEN A GIVEN NAME ENDS IN S AS IN CHARLES, PLEASE? IS IT CHARLESīCAR OR CHARLESīS CAR? I APPRECIATE YOUR HELP IN ADVANCE, THANKS! MARY |
25 Sep 2010
|
|
|
|

yanogator
|
The "rules" vary from person to person. I prefer the simplest rule, which is the same for names as for other words:
All singular nouns (and names) add īs to form the possessive
the book īs cover
the glass īs rim
Charles īs book
For plurals, use ī if the word ends in s, or īs otherwise
the books ī covers
the children īs books
the Smiths ī house (NOT the Smith īs house, as many people in the US would write)
These are not the only "correct" rules, but they are the simplest, so I recommend them.
Bruce |
25 Sep 2010
|
|

Mar0919
|
I would have to differ with the words or names that end in "s".... for words ending in "S" the rule says to add "ES"....
glass - glasses
bus - busses
for NAMES... I would go with:
This is sweater of Charles - This is Charles ī sweater... |
25 Sep 2010
|
|

lizsantiago
|
both ways are accepted you can either say charles ī book or charles īs book. |
25 Sep 2010
|
|

kiaras
|
THANKS A LOT, SWEETHEARTS! THAT WAS VERY ENLIGHTNING! HAVE A NICE WEEKEND! MAR: BE CAREFUL WITH THE COMMENTS YOU MAKE! THANK YOU, ANYWAY! |
25 Sep 2010
|
|

ascincoquinas
|
HELLO, DEAR KIARAS!
I īVE JUST UPLOADED A WORKSHEET ABOUT THIS TOPIC TODAY.... THE RULES ARE VERY CLEAR ALONG WITH SOME EXERCISES.
HAVE A GREAT WEEKEND!
ASCINCOQUINAS. |
25 Sep 2010
|
|

Mar0919
|
Be careful? Why? I was just expressing my opinion from what I was taught. I learned English in the U.S, as I grew up and did all my schooling there, (in a regular school, not language institute) But obviously it is very valid to have different opinions and we might use grammar a bit differently depending on where we learned, live, etc.
I have seen many different topics in many wonderful worksheets here that have different points of view, thus all are valuable.
Have a great weekend, everybody!!!
Mar |
25 Sep 2010
|
|

libertybelle
|
The main rule I was taught, was that if a name or a plural word ends in S - the apostrophe comes after the S. - Charles ī book - but St. James īs Park in London is spelled James īs. That could be a left-over from olden times - but most often the apostrophe comes after the S if the word or name ends in S.
The Jones ī house.
|
25 Sep 2010
|
|
|
|