|   
			ESL Forum: 
			
			
			
			Techniques and methods 
			in Language Teaching 
			
			Games, activities 
			and teaching ideas 
			
			Grammar and 
			Linguistics 
			
			
			Teaching material 
			
			
			Concerning 
			worksheets 
			
			
			Concerning 
			powerpoints 
			
			
			Concerning online 
			exercises 
			
			
			Make suggestions, 
			report errors 
			
			
			Ask for help 
			
			
			
			Message board 
			  
			
			
			
			
			 | 
 		
		
		ESL forum >
		
		
		Ask for help > knock something off a column/ down from a column???     
			
		 knock something off a column/ down from a column??? 
		
			| 
				
					| 
					
					
 
 Aldegunde
 
   | 
						
							| knock something off a column/ down from a column??? 
 |  
							| Good morning everybody!         I wish a wonderful week to all of you!!  Before asking the question I need to clarify, I want to thank anitarobi  and the rest of the people who tried to help me last week with their answers. And now, here is my new question, there is an idea I need to express and I don �t know the right way to do it: imagine someone is shaking a high column to make the image on it fall, would any of these options be right:-They knocked over the image from de column -They knocked off the image -They knocked the image down from the column -Maybe something completely different from the options above??      These kind of things get me down, I feel I �ll never master the English language! Thanks in advance
 |  23 May 2011      
					
					 |  |  
			| 
 
					
					
					
				 
 |  
			| 
				
					| 
					
					
 
 mariec
 
   | 
						
							|     I wouldn�t use the verb  "knock off,"  "break off" would be more appropriate, and in the    passive.    The statue has been broken off the column.   or if intentionally;  The statue has been removed from the column.      Have a good day. |  23 May 2011     
					
                     |  |  
			| 
				
					| 
					
					
 
 yanogator
 
   | 
						
							| With "knock off", you must separate the two words: They knocked the statue off of the column (pedestal?). This is the most natural sounding choice. They knocked the statue over. Because of "over", you can �t add the part about the column. Your third choice is OK, but sounds very formal.   I hope this helps you.   Bruce |  23 May 2011     
					
                     |  |  
	
	   |