|
Petpet
|
Confused
|
|
Dear moderators,
I checked the comments section and I can �t see any comments, only that 50 per cent of you decided it did not follow the rules. Can anyone tell me the reason why?
I tried to make the activities more interesting by adding my own ideas.
I �m sorry about posting this message here, but I have not found another way to contact you.
Petra
|
15 Jun 2009
|
|
|
|
susiebelle
|
|
I am also wondering why this was removed. I didn �t vote and I didn �t see the original ws. It �s hard to see the thumbnail view on the link. I looked at Petra �s other ws and it looks to be in the same style as her other conversation starters for other subjects. Why was it removed????
Susiebelle |
15 Jun 2009
|
|
|
Tere-arg
|
Same here.
I do not understand the reason for the removal.
It is true we cannot see much of the worksheet now, but it does not seem to break any rule.
So...?
|
15 Jun 2009
|
|
|
David Lisgo
|
|
I didn �t see it, perhaps it looked too similar to a previous worksheet and was mistakenly reported as being uploaded twice or something. Check the rules again, make some obvious changes and upload it again. Write plenty about it in your description and cross your fingers. |
15 Jun 2009
|
|
|
Anna P
|
|
Your note is directed to moderators but anyone can report a printable - the member does not need to be a moderator. In my opinion, reporting should not be anonymous. It would certainly avoid unfair reports, as it seems to be the case here.
I also don �t understand why your work has been reported and removed. In the new system moderators cannot write comments or post their names.
I don �t remember seeing your ws in the reporting page. Maybe whoever voted to remove it could explain. |
15 Jun 2009
|
|
|
alien boy
|
Anyone can report an upload, true...
but the removal was voted by the moderators irrespective of the comments above.... so if the worksheet should not have been removed the authority to retain it was still with the moderators & not the initial reporter, so don�t forget to take responsibility for your voting as moderators rather than just blaming the individual who reported it.
The report alone doesn�t decide the validity of a worksheet - it�s the moderators� votes that do!
|
15 Jun 2009
|
|
|
sazzag
|
|
Hi. I remember seeing this worksheet on the reported contributions page and it was reported because "half of it was from one of the Reward Resource Packs". I use that book and I know some of it was taken from there but not all of it. Why don �t you make some changes and re-upload the worksheet. Then I am sure it will be fine. |
15 Jun 2009
|
|
|
ssrl10
|
|
Always the same. Why aren�t people consistent in their voting? We cannot vote against the removal of a contribution because it is only partially copied one day and remove another one the following day due to the same reason. Either we vote for the removal of both or we vote against the removal of any of them.
I did not vote yesterday but I have seen this happen many times and I think that we should always follow the same rules when voting. |
15 Jun 2009
|
|
|
sazzag
|
|
I agree with you ssrl10 that this inconsistency is at best unhelpful and at worst unfair.
Maybe that is why it seems that now on the reported worksheet page when you click on the image it doesn �t show the author �s name anymore. Hopefully this will lead to more objective voting.
In this specific case Petpet wanted to know the comments on her worksheet which is why I explained what I had read and tried to offer a helpful suggestion. |
15 Jun 2009
|
|
